


Cream of the Crop:
Food Science Flavors High-Impact Ag
Research
|
by
Christopher King, Editor
|
|
ssessing
research performance that might literally involve being out standing in a
field, Science Watch here examines agricultural sciences over the last
decade. Table
#1 below
ranks institutions according to two separate measures: in the left-hand column,
total citations, and, at right, impact, or citations per paper, while
table #2,
also below,
features
highly cited researchers and most-cited journals. The
most-cited journals are listed in the
table to the immediate right.
Most-Cited Journals in
Agricultural Sciences, 1996-2006
(Ranked by citations to papers published and
cited between 1996 and 2006)
| Rank |
Journal |
Citations
|
| 1 |
J. Agricultural & Food Chemistry |
91,594 |
| 2 |
Journal of Nutrition |
59,757 |
| 3 |
Journal of Dairy Science |
35,578 |
| 4 |
Journal of Food Protection |
25,096 |
| 5 |
Intl. J. Food Microbiology |
21,613 |
| 6 |
British Journal of Nutrition |
19,721 |
| 7 |
Crop Science |
19,256 |
| 8 |
Journal of Food Science |
18,788 |
| 9 |
Food Chemistry |
17,000 |
| 10 |
J. Sci. Food & Agriculture |
14,915 |
| 11 |
J. Amer. Oil Chemists Soc. |
14,684 |
| 12 |
Meat Science |
11,792 |
| 13 |
Food & Chemical Toxicology |
11,666 |
| 14 |
J. AOAC International |
11,410 |
| 15 |
International Dairy Journal |
10,145 |
|
|
These figures derive from Thomson Scientific’s Essential
Science Indicators
and are based on papers published in 118 Thomson-indexed journals
of agricultural sciences between January 1996 and February 2006 and
cited over the same period.
Among institutions, the U.S. Department of Agriculture
(USDA) clearly shows its clout, with a total-citations count nearly
twice that of the #2-ranked institution, France’s INRA (Institut
National de la Recherche Agronomique). Size is clearly an advantage
here, with the USDA’s count of 6,600+ agricultural-sciences papers for
the decade more than doubling the INRA’s tally (again, the second
highest) of 3,000 papers.
In the top five of the total-citations column, two
institutions stand out: Wageningen University, in the Netherlands, and
the University of California, Davis. In both cases, the output and
impact of their agricultural-sciences research compares with that
produced under the aegis of large national agencies, including not only
the USDA and INRA but Spain’s CSIC (Consejo Superior de
Investigaciones Cientificas).
The measure of impact, meanwhile, as it often does,
provides a slightly different picture. In this column, the University of
Helsinki, despite a comparatively modest output of 667 ag-science papers
between 1996 and 2006, scores the highest cites-per-paper mark of any
institution in the survey. Ireland’s University College Cork similarly
distinguishes itself, ranking in the top five for impact based on only
638 papers. Also notable for their appearances in the impact column are
the University of Massachusetts (519 papers), Oregon State University
(635), Rutgers University (551) and Washington State University (853).
[Note: in the instances of identical impact scores, priority was
determined by the average prior to rounding.]
A glance at the list of researchers demonstrates that,
over the last decade, high-impact research in agricultural sciences has
weighed heavily, as it were, toward food science and nutrition.
Top-cited author Ronald L. Prior of the USDA, for example, contributed
to three of the ten most-cited papers in this survey— along with his
then-USDA colleague Guohua Cao. Their 1996 report "Total
antioxidant capacity of fruits," (H. Wang, G.H. Cao, R.L. Prior, J.
Agr. Chem., 44[3]: 701-5, 1996) is the second-most-cited paper in
this study, with more than 360 citations. (Cao, incidentally, has since
switched fields to computer science.) The survey’s most-cited paper is
L. Bravo, "Polyphenols: Chemistry, dietary sources, metabolism, and
nutritional significance," Nutr. Rev., 56(11): 317-33, 1998,
with roughly 390 citations. Of the ten most-cited agricultural-sciences
papers, in fact, all deal with aspects of nutrition and food science.
Among the 25 highly cited authors, only Dennis Baldocchi
(#19) of the University of California, Berkeley, has something besides
food on his research plate. An environmental scientist, Baldocchi
concentrates on the processes controlling the various exchanges between
vegetation and the atmosphere. And Andrew L. Waterhouse of the
University of California, Davis, (#16) also has a slightly different
concentration and perhaps the most enviable job of all: the study of
wine.
[Table
1]
Agricultural Sciences
Institutions Ranked by Citations and
Citation Impact
(among those that published
≥ 500 papers, 1996-2006)
|
| Rank |
Institution |
Citations
1996-
2006 |
| 1 |
U.S.
Dept. Agriculture |
41,204 |
| 2 |
INRA
(France) |
22,847 |
| 3 |
Wageningen
University |
16,370 |
| 4 |
CSIC
(Spain) |
16,069 |
| 5 |
Univ.
Calif., Davis |
13,554 |
| 6 |
CSIRO
(Australia) |
11,958 |
| 7 |
Cornell
University |
11,261 |
| 8 |
University
of Wisconsin |
10,929 |
| 9 |
Agricult.
& Agri-Food Canada |
10,847 |
| 10 |
University
of Georgia |
8,905 |
| 11 |
Iowa
State University |
8,299 |
| 12 |
University
of Guelph |
8,057 |
| 13 |
University
of Illinois |
7,718 |
| 14 |
University
of Minnesota |
7,567 |
| 15 |
Royal
Vet. & Agr. U., Denmark |
6,647 |
| 16 |
University
of Florida |
6,616 |
| 17 |
University
of Nebraska |
6,553 |
| 18 |
Michigan
State University |
6,186 |
| 19 |
U.S.
Food & Drug Admin. |
6,183 |
| 20 |
University
of Helsinki |
6,126 |
| 21 |
University
of Reading |
5,939 |
| 22 |
Ohio
State University |
5,764 |
| 23 |
Pennsylvania
State University |
5,588 |
| 24 |
North
Carolina State University |
5,569 |
| 25 |
Swedish
U. Agricultural Sci. |
5,544 |
|
 |
| Rank |
Institution |
Impact
1996-
2006 |
| 1 |
University
of Helsinki |
9.05 |
| 2 |
Cornell
University |
8.47 |
| 3 |
University
of Wisconsin |
8.47 |
| 4 |
Univ.
Coll. Cork, Ireland |
8.16 |
| 5 |
Univ.
Calif., Davis |
7.89 |
| 6 |
CSIRO
(Australia) |
7.71 |
| 7 |
University
of Massachusetts |
7.63 |
| 8 |
INRA
(France) |
7.60 |
| 9 |
Oregon
State University |
7.56 |
| 10 |
Wageningen
University |
7.48 |
| 11 |
Michigan
State University |
7.32 |
| 12 |
University
of Minnesota |
7.30 |
| 13 |
University
of Reading |
7.22 |
| 14 |
University
of Guelph |
6.99 |
| 15 |
Rutgers
University |
6.92 |
| 16 |
Royal
Vet. & Agr. U., Denmark |
6.90 |
| 17 |
Iowa
State University |
6.85 |
| 18 |
University
of Illinois |
6.75 |
| 19 |
U.S.
Food & Drug. Admin. |
6.69 |
| 20 |
Pennsylvania
State University |
6.68 |
| 21 |
Swedish
U. Agricultural Sci. |
6.48 |
| 22 |
University
of Georgia |
6.45 |
| 23 |
CSIC
(Spain) |
6.42 |
| 24 |
Washington
State University |
6.42 |
| 25 |
University
of Nebraska |
6.38 |
|
[Table 2]
Highly Cited Authors in Agricultural Sciences, 1996-2006
(Ranked by total citations)
|
| |
Rank |
|
|
Department/
Specialty |
Papers |
Citations |
|
1 |
Ronald L. Prior |
U.S. Department of Agriculture |
Children’s
Nutrition |
41 |
2,026 |
|
2 |
Dale
E. Bauman |
Cornell
University |
Animal
Sci./Nutrition |
64 |
1,729 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
3 |
Edwin
N. Frankel |
University of California, Davis |
Food
Science |
36 |
1,647 |
| |
4 |
Guohua
Cao |
U.S. Department of Agriculture |
Food
Science |
12 |
1,509 |
|
5 |
Larry
R. Beuchat |
University
of Georgia |
Food
Science |
133 |
1,460 |
|
6 |
Patrick
F. Fox |
University
Coll. Cork |
Food/Dairy
Chemistry |
116 |
1,361 |
|
7 |
Fereidoon
Shahidi |
Memorial University of Newfoundland |
Food
Chemistry |
165 |
1,311 |
| |
8 |
D.
Julian McClements |
U.
Massachusetts |
Food
Science |
125 |
1,300 |
| |
9 |
I.
Marina Heinonen |
University
of Helsinki |
Food
Chemistry |
35 |
1,248 |
|
10 |
Leif
H. Skibsted |
Royal Veterinary & Agricultural University, Denmark |
Food
Chemistry |
144 |
1,166 |
| |
11 |
J.
Bruce German |
University of California, Davis |
Food
Chemistry |
51 |
1,158 |
|
12 |
Mendel
Friedman |
U.S. Department of Agriculture |
Foodborne
Pathogens |
49 |
1,117 |
| |
13 |
Marcel
B. Roberfroid |
Catholic University of Louvain |
Food
Toxicology |
27 |
1,097 |
|
14 |
Eric
Dickinson |
University
of Leeds |
Food
Colloids |
64 |
1,096 |
|
15 |
Harjinder
Singh |
Massey
University, NZ |
Dairy
Science |
153 |
1,075 |
|
16 |
Andrew
L. Waterhouse |
University of California, Davis |
Viticulture/
Enology |
35 |
1,014 |
| |
17 |
Gary
Williamson |
Nestle Research Center,
Switzerland |
Nutrition |
37 |
988 |
| |
18 |
Paul
L. H. McSweeney |
University
Coll. Cork |
Food
Science |
89 |
959 |
| |
19 |
Dennis
D. Baldocchi |
University of California,
Berkeley |
Ecosystem
Science |
23 |
944 |
| |
20 |
Anne
S. Meyer |
Technical University of Denmark |
Enzyme
Technology |
48 |
931 |
|
21 |
Jan
Delcour |
Catholic University of Louvain |
Food
Chemistry |
106 |
925 |
|
22 |
Barry
G. Swanson |
Washington
State U. |
Food
Science |
83 |
919 |
| |
23 |
Francisco
Tomas-Barberan |
CSIC,
Spain |
Food
Science |
72 |
902 |
|
24 |
Eric
A. Decker |
U.
Massachusetts |
Food
Chemistry |
87 |
895 |
|
25 |
Chi-Tang
Ho |
Rutgers
University |
Food
Chemistry |
98 |
891 |
| |
SOURCE:
Thomson Scientific
Essential Science Indicators |
Return
Science
Watch®, July/August 2006, Vol. 17, No. 4
Citing URL: http://www.sciencewatch.com/july-aug2006/sw_july-aug2006_page1.htm |
|