Science Watch® - Tracking Trends and Performance in Basic Research
March/April 2000


With New Data,
Solar Neutrino Conundrum Nearer Solution
by Simon Mitton



WHAT'S HOT IN PHYSICS...

Rank Paper Citations
This
Period
Nov-
Dec
99
Rank
Last Period
Sep-
Oct
99
1 Y. Fukuda, et al., "Evidence for oscillation of atmospheric neutrinos," Phys. Rev. Lett., 81(8):1652-7, 24 August 1998. [24 institutions worldwide] *112FJ 42 2
2 D.J. Schlegel, D.P. Finkbeiner, M. Davis, "Maps of dust infrared emission for use in estimation of reddening and cosmic microwave background radiation foregrounds," Astrophys. J., 500(2):525-53, 20 June 1998. [U. Durham, U.K.; U. Calif., Berkeley] *ZX419 35 3
3 A.D. Martin, et al., "Parton distributions: a new global analysis," Europ. Phys. J. C, 4(3):463-96, July 1998. [U. Durham, U.K.; Rutherford Appleton Lab, Didcot, U.K.; U. Oxford, U.K.] *104RH 33
4 N. Arkani-Hamad, S. Dimopoulos, G. Dvali, "The hierarchy problem and new dimensions at a millimeter," Phys. Lett. B, 429(3,4):263-72, 18 June 1998. [Stanford U., CA; ICTP, Trieste, Italy] *ZZ088 29 4
5 S.S. Gubser, I.R. Klebanov, A.M. Polyakov, "Gauge theory correlators from non-critical string theory," Phys. Lett. B, 428(1,2):105-14, 28 May 1998. [Princeton U., NJ] *ZY402 28 1
6 S.R. Kulkarni, et al., "Identification of a host galaxy at redshift z = 3.42 for the g-ray burst of 14 December 1997," Nature, 393(6680):35-9, 7 May 1998. [9 institutions worldwide] *ZM028 23
7 I. Antoniadis, et al., "New dimensions at a millimeter to a fermi and superstrings at a TeV" Phys. Lett. B, 436(3,4):257-63, 24 September 1998. [Ecole Polytech., Palaiseau, France; Stanford U., CA: ICTP, Trieste, Italy] *129JW 23 7
8 J.N. Bahcall, P.I. Krastev, A.Y. Smirnov, "Where do we stand with solar neutrino oscillations?" Phys. Rev. D, 58(9):6016, 1 November 1998. [Inst. Adv. Study, Princeton, NJ; U. Wisconsin, Madison; ICTP, Trieste, Italy] *134GV 20 9
9 N. Arkani-Hamed, S. Dimopoulos, G. Dvali, "Phenomenology, astrophysics, and cosmology of theories with submillimeter dimensions and TeV scale of quantum gravity," Phys Rev. D, 59(8):15 April 1999. [Stanford U., CA; ICTP, Trieste, Italy] *186XE 19
10 Y. Fukuda, et al. "Measurement of the solar neutrino flux from Super-Kamiokande's first 300 days," Phys. Rev. Lett., 81(6):1158-62, 10 August 1998. [23 institutions worldwide] *109CL 18

SOURCE: ISI's Hot Papers DatabaseRead  the full legend.

hree papers this period, #1, #8 and #10, could hold the key to one of the greatest puzzles in astrophysics, the solar neutrino problem. A solution involving startling new physics could be in sight.

   Neutrinos easily pass through matter, so a detector for solar neutrinos is a telescope looking at physics deep in the core of the Sun. Solar neutrinos, released from the dense matter that is the central nuclear furnace, pass unhindered through the Sun and journey 1.5 X 108 km to Earth where the flux is 1014 m-2 s-1. Four different experiments have now detected neutrinos from the Sun, and they all record a lower flux than that predicted by standard solar models. For 30 years this failure of theory and observation to converge has acted as the showstopper to a fuller understanding of nuclear energy generation in stars. Astrophysicists long suspected that the solution would emerge from new discoveries in neutrino physics rather than revisions to the solar models. It now looks as if those views are correct, thanks to data from the Super-Kamiokande collaboration (#1, 10).

   Super-Kamiokande (SK) is a second generation solar neutrino experiment 2.7 km underground. Its detector includes 50 kiloton of imaging water, and two cylindrical arrays of 13,000 photomultiplier tubes (PMT). In the water, neutrino-electron scattering produces relativistic electrons which emit a cone of Cherenkov light, effectively from the point of interaction. SK can reconstruct the interaction, including the direction of the incoming neutrino, from the charge and timing data of the triggered PMTs.

   In #1 (see Science Watch, 10[6]: 6, Nov/Dec 1999) Yoji Fukuda’s collaboration reported evidence that neutrinos from atmospheric cosmic-ray collisions appear to oscillate between electron and muon forms. Since the detection techniques used for solar experiments are specific to electron or muon neutrino, neutrino oscillations will cause the detector to miss part of the solar flux. Paper #1 has now been cited more than 185 times.

   The new paper from SK, #10, spanning 300 days of data from 1996-97, includes ~ 3 x 108 hits. After elimination of background events and noise, the effective solar neutrino detection rate is 7.6 (events/day) /kiloton, which translates to a flux from 8B solar neutrinos of 2.42 X 106 cm-2 s-1. There is no significant difference between daytime and night-time fluxes, nor are there seasonal variations. The new result, which is consistent with earlier Kamiokande claims, represents just 36% of the predictions of the standard solar model. This low count strongly suggests that neutrino oscillations are present.

   At the 195th meeting of the American Astronomical Society (Atlanta, GA, January 2000), Yoji Totsuka (University of Tokyo) gave an upbeat assessment of the astronomical prospects for Super-Kamiokande, which can be used for supernova alerts. No supernova has been sighted in the Milky Way galaxy since the invention of the telescope; statistically one is long overdue and is eagerly awaited. SK can act as an alarm because the neutrino pulse from a collapsed star arrives in advance of photon flood. As an early warning system SK can pinpoint the location of a galactic supernova to within 5° and within 30 minutes alert professional and amateur astronomers worldwide over the Internet.

   The theme of cosmic events setting the pace for physics continues with newcomer #9, whose authors now have a trio (#4, 7, 9) in the Physics Top Ten. They have a scheme for solving the hierarchy problem of the fundamental forces by bringing quantum gravity up to the realm of accessibility. This is achieved by invoking 2 new spatial dimensions of sub-mm scale. Gravity is posited to operate in these new dimensions, but the Standard Model forces are shut out. Paper #9 looks at whether anything we already know in physics and cosmology rules out the scheme. It explores extreme astrophysical environments such as 108 TeV cosmic rays, extragalactic supernova explosions, and benchtop observables. The good news is that nothing rules out a 6-dimensional Planck scale. So an exciting vista of new physics beckons, including an experimental probing of quantum gravity.

   Our highest-ranking newcomer, leaping in at #3, is a new global analysis of quark-gluon physics inside the proton. Parton distributions show how the quarks and gluons are distributed over a wide range of conditions, and they give a global fit to a wide range of deep inelastic and hard scattering data. The Durham University group has made a specialty of regularly reviewing all published data from scattering experiments in order to refine the distributions.end 

Dr. Simon Mitton is science director of Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.


Science Watch®, March/April 2000, Vol. 11, No. 2
Citing URL: http://www.sciencewatch.com/march-april2000/sw_march-april2000_page6.htm

Search | March/April 2000 Index | Archives | Contact | Home

What's New in Research - (Updated weekly) - What's NEW in Research
The Most-Cited Researchers in...
  |  Analysis Of...  |  Site Map by Field | ! QUICK SCIENCE !
Alphabetized List of All Essential Science Indicators Editorial Features/Interviews


Science Watch® is an editorial component of Essential Science Indicators. RSS Feeds for Essential Science Indicator's editorial Web sites
Visit other editorial components of ESI: "in-cites" and "Special Topics."
Write to the Webmaster with questions or comments about this site. Terms of Usage.
View all the products of the Research Services Group from Thomson Scientific.


(c) 2008 The Thomson Corporation.
Thomson Scientific