Science Watch® - Tracking Trends and Performance in Basic Research
MAY/JUNE 2003


Two Years of Magnesium Diboride
by Simon Mitton
WHAT'S HOT IN PHYSICS
Rank      Paper Citations This Period (Nov-Dec 02) Rank Last Period (Sep-Oct 02)
1  J. Nagamatsu, et al., "Superconductivity at 39K in magnesium diboride,"  Nature, 410(6824): 63-4, 1 March 2001 . [ Aoyama-Gakuin U. , Tokyo , Japan ; Japan Sci. Technol. Corp., Saitama]  *406BD 103 1
2 Q.R. Ahmad, et al., "Measurement of the rate of nee, + d  à p + p + é interactions produced by 8B solar neutrinos at the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory," Phys. Rev. Lett., 87(7): 1301, 13 August 2001 .  [15 institutions worldwide]  *463LU 52 9
3 S. L. Bud’ko, et al., "Boron isotope effect in superconducting MgB2,"  Phys. Rev. Lett., 86(9): 1877-80, 26 February 2001 . [Iowa St. U., Ames ] *405RF 35 2
4 S. Fukuda, et al., "Solar 8B and hep neutrino measurements from 1258 days of Super-Kamiokande data,"  Phys. Rev. Lett., 86(25): 5651-5, 18 June 2001 . [27 institutions worldwide]  *443ZG 35 6
5 R.R. Metsaev, "Type IIB Green-Schwartz superstring in plane wave Ramond-Ramond background,"  Nucl. Phys. B, 625:70-96,  18 March 2002 . [Lebedev Phys. Inst., Moscow , Russia ] *531CY 34 7
6 J. Kortus, et al., "Superconductivity of metallic boron in MgB2,"  Phys. Rev. Lett., 86(20): 4656-9, 14 May 2001 .  [Max Planck Inst. Solid State Res., Stuttgart, Germany; Georgetown U., Washington, D.C.; Naval Res. Lab., Washington, D.C.; Iowa St. U., Ames]  *431GM.
See Also | See Also | See Also
33 3
7 Q.R. Ahmad, et al., "Direct evidence for neutrino flavor transformation from neutral-current interactions in the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory,"  Phys. Rev. Lett., 89(1): 1301, 1 July 2002 . [17 institutions worldwide]   *563YN 30
8 J.M. An, W.E. Pickett, "Superconductivity of MgB2: Covalent bonds driven metallic,"  Phys. Rev. Lett., 86(19): 4366-9, 7 May 2001 .  [U. Calif. , Davis]  *430TE 29
9 S. Fukuda, et al.,  "Constraints on neutrino oscillations using 1258 days of Super-Kamiokande solar neutrino data,"  Phys. Rev. Lett., 86(25):5656-60, 18 June 2001 . [27 institutions worldwide]  *443ZG 28
10 P.C. Canfield, et al., "Superconductivity in dense MgB2 wires,"  Phys. Rev. Lett., 86(11): 2423-6, 12 March 2001 .  [ Ames Lab., IA; Iowa St. U., Ames ] *410NC 25
SOURCE: ISI’s Hot Papers DatabaseRead  the Legend. 

It is a little over two years since the announcement that magnesium diboride (MgB2) becomes a superconductor at a high transition temperature of 40 K. Hot paper #1 reached the pinnacle within four months of publication, and has now earned more than 640 citations, boosted by an impressive 103 hits in the current period. Clearly this is a paper that has transformed research into superconductors, and Thomson ISI’s citation analysis gave an early warning that this paper was going to be a "big one." MgB2 has turned out to be far more interesting, and surprising, than Jun Akimitsu can possibly have imagined when he reported the discovery in January 2001.
(View the Special Topic of Magnesium Diboride Superconductors in ESI Special Topics.)

     Kammerlingh Onnes discovered superconductivity, in mercury, in 1911, winning the Nobel Prize in 1913 for his work with liquid helium. For the next 80 years research on superconductors was held back because the highest transition temperature (Tc) was only 23 K. This meant all research required challenging cryogenics at liquid helium temperatures, and applications were limited to mega-projects, such as the superconducting magnets in particle accelerators.

     All this changed a decade ago with the discovery of high-Tc copper oxide ceramic superconductors. A new kind of physics emerged, with a language of its own: pseudogaps, stripes, and new pairing mechanisms. Tc climbed ever higher, reaching 160 K under pressure. The theorists struggled to understand the mechanisms, and the experimentalists tweaked the doping, composition, and physical structure of the multi-element compounds in their search for a superconducting structure that could be made easily. The superconducting devices currently being made require a complex processing.

     It took until 1957 to explain the mechanism of superconductivity. In that year John Bardeen, Leon Cooper, and Robert Schrieffer showed how an electron-phonon interaction could produce the electron pairs. This theory explained the puzzle of the isotope effect: Tc falls as the mass of the superconducting atoms increases. That’s because the lattice vibrations (the phonons) depend on the masses of the atoms in the lattice.

     The isotope effect suggested that compounds rich in the light elements would be a good hunting ground for high-Tc materials. Akimitsu’s group, for example, was looking at the Ti-B-Mg phase diagram, and other researchers were trawling three-element and four-element compounds. But the binary compound MgB2 turned out to be the long-sought high-Tc material. The point about a Tc of 40 K is that inexpensive refrigerators can cool to this level.

     MgB2 cannot be grown into crystals, and that may be why it was missed for so long. It is made as a grey powder from the reaction of B with Mg vapor at a temperature of 900° C. To add to the excitement of the high Tc, here was a superconductor made from elements that are abundant and inexpensive, in contrast to the copper-oxides, with their rare earth elements. Furthermore, it is so easy to make and to handle that superconducting research groups worldwide were able to get into MgB2 research immediately, and this accessibility accounts for the high citations of #1.

     When MgB2’s properties were announced, theorists were still struggling with a theory for the cuprates. Imagine the relief then when Sergei Bud’ko and coworkers announced in #3 that they had found the isotope effect. This immediately signalled that MgB2 is an "old-fashioned" superconductor that everyone could understand. The high citations to this paper are from researchers who gladly acknowledge that the physics of MgB2 is familiar!

     Hot Paper #10 from Paul Canfield’s group is remarkable for the speed with which the team made MgB2 wires. Obviously, if MgB2 is to be fabricated into magnets, then wires and films are a must. The technique outlined in #10 is simplicity itself: they suspended a commercially available B fiber in Mg vapor and turned it into a brittle wire. In a similar manner they have made MgB2 films from B films. Another attractive feature for MgB2 in terms of magnet and electronic applications is its low molecular weight and very low mass density. It’s a lightweight material that could have important applications in space.

     The "how does it work?" question is answered in #6, from Jens Kortus and colleagues. They showed that B forms layers of honeycomb lattices with hexagonal planes of Mg as a space filler. The high level of Tc is attributed to the remarkable strength of the electron-phonon interaction.

     The five MgB2 papers on the list have logged a total of 1,400+ citations, which is startlingly high for the Physics Top Ten. New areas for pure and applied research have been mapped out. Medical applications of this promising material, in MRI scanners, may not be far off. And MgB2 has taught us a lesson about how to do science. Despite 80 years of searches it was missed. No theorist predicted this behavior. The discovery was made as a result of the patient experimental search for new compounds. end  

Dr. Simon Mitton is a Director of Total Astronomy Ltd, Cambridge, U.K.

Read an interview with Paul Canfield discussing the Special Topic of Magnesium Diboride Superconductors in ESI Special Topics.  

See Dr. Jens Kortus rankings in the Special Topic Magnesium Diboride Superconductors, in Top 25 Papers (#17) and Top Authors (in both total citations and cites per paper).  Also, Dr. Kortus answers a few questions about his Fast Breaking Paper in the field of Physics for June 2002.

Science Watch®, MAY/JUNE 2003, Vol. 14, No. 3
Citing URL: http://www.sciencewatch.com/may-june2003/sw_may-june2003_page6.htm

Search | May/Jun 2003 Index | Archives | Contact | Home

What's New in Research - (Updated weekly) - What's NEW in Research
The Most-Cited Researchers in...
  |  Analysis Of...  |  Site Map by Field | ! QUICK SCIENCE !
Alphabetized List of All Essential Science Indicators Editorial Features/Interviews


Science Watch® is an editorial component of Essential Science Indicators. RSS Feeds for Essential Science Indicator's editorial Web sites
Visit other editorial components of ESI: "in-cites" and "Special Topics."
Write to the Webmaster with questions or comments about this site. Terms of Usage.
View all the products of the Research Services Group from Thomson Scientific.


(c) 2008 The Thomson Corporation.
Thomson Scientific