


| Vetting Who's Best with the Beasts |
|
|
 cience
Watch now turns its attention to
research in veterinary medicine and animal health over the last decade. To
survey this field, Science Watch extracted more than 140,000
papers published between 1994 and 2004 in upwards of 150 Thomson
Scientific-indexed journals categorized under the headings of "veterinary
sciences," "veterinary medicine," and "animal health."
From this selection of literature, Science Watch identified, in table
#1 below, the top institutions as measured by both total citations and by
impact (citations per paper). Table #2 (below) features
the most-cited individual authors, along with the most-cited journals dedicated
to veterinary research.
|
Most-Cited Journals Dedicated to
Veterinary Medicine, 1994-2004
(Ranked by citations to papers
published
and cited between 1994 and 2004)
| Rank |
Journal |
Citations |
| 1 |
Theriogenology |
22,572 |
| 2 |
Veterinary
Record |
21,401 |
| 3 |
J.
Amer. Vet. Med. Assoc. |
20,776 |
| 4 |
Amer.
J. Veterinary Res. |
18,355 |
| 5 |
Veterinary
Microbiology |
15,315 |
| 6 |
Veterinary
Parasitology |
14,072 |
| 7 |
Vet.
Immunol. & Immunopathol. |
12,557 |
| 8 |
J.
Medical Entomology |
8,916 |
| 9 |
Avian
Diseases |
7,836 |
| 10 |
J.
Veterinary Medical Science |
7,470 |
| 11 |
J.
Veter. Diagnostic Investigat. |
7,131 |
| 12 |
Veterinary
Pathology |
6,728 |
| 13 |
Equine
Veterinary Journal |
6,301 |
| 14 |
Res.
in Veterinary Science |
6,027 |
| 15 |
Journal
of Wildlife Diseases |
5,548 |
|
|
Among the institutions ranked by total citations, none surpassed
the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), whose authors contributed to some
1,900 papers during the 11-year period; collectively, these papers garnered more
than 15,500 citations. The most-cited paper in this survey, in fact, was
coauthored by a USDA-affiliated author. "A review of Neospora caninum
and neosporosis," published in 1996 in Veterinary Parasitology
(67[1-2]: 1-59, 1996), has now been cited more than 350 times. This discussion
of the protozoan parasite Neospora caninum was co-written by USDA
microbiologist Jitender P. Dubey, who appears atop the list of researchers, with
2,264 citations to his published work over the last decade. The paper’s other
author, David S. Lindsay, now at the Virginia Polytechnic Institute, is at #6 on
the list of highly cited researchers.
The University of California, Davis, also distinguished itself
in the total-citations ranking, with its output of 2,498 papers (the largest of
all the institutions in this survey) attracting a total of more than 13,600
citations. The authors of UC Davis’s most-cited paper (J. Pare, et al.,
Can. J. Vet Res., 60[2]: 133-9, 1996) include two of the scientists
featured here: Mark C. Thurmond (#9) and Sharon K. Hietala (#13). Like the Dubey
et al. report mentioned above, the paper by Pare, Thurmond, and Hietala
(with more than 140 citations to date) also concerns the Neospora caninum
parasite and its effects.
In the impact ranking, the Department of Agriculture and Rural
Development of Northern Ireland (DARDNI) made the most of its 272 papers,
topping the list with an average of more than 10 citations per paper. The
most-cited DARDNI report, a 1998 paper from the Canadian Veterinary Journal (39[1]:
44-55, 1998), includes among its authors Gordon M. Allan (#3 on the list) and
DARDNI colleague Francis McNeilly (#4). The report is also the most cited in
this survey for the University of Saskatchewan, represented here by the paper’s
first author, John A. Ellis (#2), and by Deborah M. Haines (#7).
Among journals, Theriogenology was tops with more than
22,500 citations to its 3,407 papers published between 1994 and 2004.
Incidentally, papers from the journal Vaccine were included in the
survey, but the journal itself was excluded from the accompanying table (to the
right), despite its dominant count of nearly 46,000 citations. Many of Vaccine’s
4,912 papers concern veterinary medicine and animal health, but many others
center on larger matters of infectious disease, immunization, vaccination, and
the like. Science Watch elected to confine the table to specialty
journals in veterinary and animal research.
Clearly, UC Davis and DARDNI stand out, both for institutional
performance and for the numbers of their researchers who figure among the highly
cited authors featured here. Other institutions that managed to make both the
total-citations and impact lists are the USDA, Ohio State University, the
Institute for Animal Health, the University of Saskatchewan, the University of
Wisconsin, the University of Minnesota, Wageningen University, the Swedish
University of Agricultural Sciences, the Royal Veterinary and Agricultural
University of Denmark, Washington State University, and the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention.
Table#1: 
Veterinary
/ Animal Research
Institutions Ranked by Citations and
Citation Impact
(Among those that published ³
200)
veterinary medicine papers 1994-2004) |
|
| Rank |
Institution |
Citations
1994 - 2004 |
| 1 |
U.S.
Department of Agriculture |
15,541 |
| 2 |
University
of California, Davis |
13,662 |
| 3 |
Ohio
State University |
7,521 |
| 4 |
University
of Utrecht |
7,386 |
| 5 |
Colorado
State University |
6,738 |
| 6 |
Cornell
University |
6,614 |
| 7 |
University
of Wisconsin |
6,147 |
| 8 |
University
of Minnesota |
6,105 |
| 9 |
University
of Guelph |
6,015 |
| 10 |
University
of Georgia |
5,939 |
| 11 |
University
of Pennsylvania |
5,927 |
| 12 |
North
Carolina State University |
5,859 |
| 13 |
Texas
A&M University |
5,676 |
| 14 |
University
of Saskatchewan |
5597 |
| 15 |
University
of Florida |
5,524 |
| 16 |
Wageningen
University |
5,118 |
| 17 |
INRA
(France) |
4,965 |
| 18 |
Michigan
State University |
4,710 |
| 19 |
Swedish
Univ. Agricultural Sciences |
4,605 |
| 20 |
University
of Bristol |
4,413 |
| 21 |
Royal
Vet. and Agricult. Univ. (Denmark) |
4,336 |
| 22 |
University
of Illinois |
4,288 |
| 23 |
Washington
State University |
4,245 |
| 24 |
Institute
for Animal Health (U.K.) |
4,110 |
| 25 |
Ctrs.
Disease Control and Prevention |
3,991 |
|
 |
| Rank |
Institution |
Impact
1994 - 2004 |
| 1 |
Dept.
Agricult. & Rural Dev. No. Ireland |
10.31 |
| 2 |
Institut
Pasteur |
9.72 |
| 3 |
University
of Maryland |
8.98 |
| 4 |
Ctrs.
Disease Control and Prevention |
8.83 |
| 5 |
Danish
Veterinary Laboratory |
8.75 |
| 6 |
Institute
for Animal Health (U.K.) |
8.56 |
| 7 |
Wageningen
University |
8.24 |
| 8 |
U.S.
Department of Agriculture |
8.08 |
| 9 |
Moredun
Research Institute (Scotland) |
7.48 |
| 10 |
CSIRO
(Australia) |
7.41 |
| 11 |
U.S.
Army |
6.96 |
| 12 |
Agriculture
and Agri-Food Canada |
6.66 |
| 13 |
National
Veterinary Institute (Sweden) |
6.45 |
| 14 |
U.S.
Food & Drug Administration |
6.39 |
| 15 |
University
of Nebraska |
6.10 |
| 16 |
University
of Wisconsin |
5.78 |
| 17 |
Swedish
Univ. Agricultural Sciences |
5.74 |
| 18 |
Washington
State University |
5.65 |
| 19 |
Ohio
State University |
5.65 |
| 20 |
University
of Saskatchewan |
5.60 |
| 21 |
Animal
Medical Center, N.Y. |
5.55 |
| 22 |
University
of Minnesota |
5.50 |
| 23 |
University
of California, Davis |
5.47 |
| 24 |
Royal
Vet. and Agricult. Univ. (Denmark) |
5.40 |
| 25 |
Iowa
State University |
5.35 |
|
Table#2:

Highly
Cited Authors in Veterinary Medicine, 1994-2004
(Ranked by total citations) |
| Rank |
|
|
Papers |
Avg.
cites per paper |
Citations |
| 1 |
Jitender P. Dubey |
U.S.
Dept. of Agriculture |
153 |
14.80 |
2,264 |
| 2 |
John A.
Ellis |
University
of Saskatchewan |
91 |
18.60 |
1,693 |
| 3 |
Gordon
M. Allan |
Dept.
Agr. Rural Devel. North. Ireland |
64 |
25.25 |
1,616 |
| 4 |
Francis
McNeilly |
Dept.
Agr. Rural Devel. North. Ireland |
56 |
23.34 |
1,307 |
| 5 |
Seamus
Kennedy |
Dept.
Agr. Rural Devel. North. Ireland |
56 |
20.70 |
1,159 |
| 6 |
David S.
Lindsay |
Virginia
Polytechnic Institute |
64 |
17.44 |
1,116 |
| 7 |
Deborah
M. Haines |
University
of Saskatchewan |
78 |
13.88 |
1,083 |
| 8 |
Jan T.
van Oirschot |
Wageningen University |
74 |
12.77 |
945 |
| 9 |
Mark C.
Thurmond |
Univ. of
California, Davis |
46 |
18.83 |
866 |
| 10 |
Albert
D.M.E. Osterhaus |
Erasmus University |
100 |
8.56 |
856 |
| 11 |
Steven
Krakowka |
Ohio
State University |
41 |
20.71 |
849 |
| 12 |
Michael
Balls |
ECVAM,
Ispra, Italy |
105 |
7.57 |
795 |
| 13 |
Sharon
K. Hietala |
Univ. of
California, Davis |
41 |
19.29 |
791 |
| 14 |
Ynte H.
Schukken |
Cornell
University |
75 |
10.25 |
769 |
| 15 |
Ian R.
Gardner |
Univ. of
California, Davis |
95 |
8.08 |
768 |
| 16 |
Philip
H. Kass |
Univ. of
California, Davis |
127 |
5.44 |
691 |
| 17 |
Horst
Spielmann |
Fed.
Inst. Risk Assessment, Berlin |
31 |
22.19 |
688 |
| 18 |
Heather
L. Davis |
Coley
Pharmaceutical Group |
16 |
42.94 |
687 |
| 19 |
Noah D.
Cohen |
Texas
A&M University |
99 |
6.83 |
676 |
| 20 |
Patricia
A. Conrad |
Univ. of
California, Davis |
23 |
28.48 |
655 |
| 21 |
Takeshi
Mikami |
Nihon
University |
111 |
5.87 |
652 |
| 22 |
Brian M.
Adair |
Dept.
Agr. Rural Devel. No. Ireland |
45 |
14.36 |
646 |
| 23 |
Alexander
J. Trees |
University
of Liverpool |
37 |
17.41 |
644 |
| 24 |
Bradd C.
Barr |
Univ. of
California, Davis |
24 |
26.50 |
636 |
| 25 |
Mark L.
Anderson |
Univ. of
California, Davis |
23 |
26.74 |
615 |
| SOURCE:
Topical Citation Report:
Veterinary Medicine, 1994 -2004 |

Science
Watch®, May/June 2005, Vol. 16, No. 3
Citing URL: http://www.sciencewatch.com/may-june2005/sw_may-june2005_page1.htm |
|