Science Watch® - Tracking Trends and Performance In Basic Research
November/December 1999


M. tuberculosis Sequence Yields New Proteins,
New Possibilities
by Jeremy Cherfas




WHAT'S HOT IN BIOLOGY...

Rank Paper Citations
This
Period
Jul-
Aug
99
Rank
Last Period
May-
Jun
99
1 S. F. Altschul, et al., "Gapped BLAST and PSI-BLAST: a new generation of protein database search programs," Nucleic Acids Res., 25(17):3389-3402, 1 September 1997. [NIH, Bethesda, MD; Pennsylvania St. U., University Park] *XU793 180 1
2 D.A. Doyle, et al., "Structure of the potassium channel: Molecular basis of K+ conduction and selectivity," Science, 280(5360):69-77, 3 April 1998. [Rockefeller U., New York, NY; Howard Hughes Med. Inst., Rockefeller U., NY] *ZF314 73 6
3 F.R. Blattner, et al., "The complete genome sequence of Escherichia coli K-12," Science, 277(5331):1453-74, 5 September 1997. [U. Wisconsin, Madison; U. Michigan Sch. Med., Ann Arbor; FMC Bioproducts, Rockland, ME; U. Natl. Autonoma Mexico, Moreles] *XV429 70 4
4 P. Li, et al., "Cytochrome c and dATP-dependent formation of Apaf-1/Caspase-9 complex initiates an apoptotic protease cascade," Cell, 91(4):479-89, 14 November 1997. [Howard Hughes Med. Inst., U. Texas Southwest. Med. Ctr., Dallas; Thomas Jefferson U., Philadelphia, PA] YG492 48 2
5 J.-F.Tomb, et al., "The complete genome sequence of the gastric pathogen Helicobacter pylori," Nature, 388(6642):539-47, 7 August 1997. [6 U.S. and Swedish institutions] *XP722 42 8
6 S.T. Cole, et al., "Deciphering the biology of Mycobacterium tuberculosis from the complete genome sequence," Nature, 393(6685):537, 11 June 1998. [Sanger Ctr., Hinxton, England; Inst. Pasteur, Paris, France; NIAID, NIH, Hamilton, MT; Tech. U. Denmark, Lyngby] *ZT988 42
7 F. Kunst, et al., "The complete genome sequence of the Gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis," Nature, 390(6657):249-56, 20 November 1997. [46 institutions worldwide] *YG667 41 7
8 H. Zou, et al., "Apaf-1, a human protein homologous to C. elegans CED-4, participates in cytochrome c-dependent activation of caspase-3," Cell,90(3):405-13, 8 August 1997. [U. Texas Southwestern Med. Ctr. Dallas; Genentech, South San Francisco, CA] *XQ063 40 3

 

9 M. Enari, et al., "A caspase-activated DNase that degrades DNA during apoptosis, and its inhibitor ICAD," Nature, 391(6662):43-50, 1 January 1998. [Osaka U. Med. Sch., Japan; Kirin Brewery Co., Kanagawa, Japan; Osaka Biosci. Inst., Japan] *YP888 39 5
10 S.R. Datta, et al., "Akt phosphorylation of BAD couples survival signals to the cell-intrinsic death machinery," Cell, 91(2):231-41, 17 October 1997. [Harvard Med. Sch., Boston, MA: Emory U., Atlanta, GA] *YC350 38

SOURCE: ISI's Hot Papers Database.  Read  the full legend.

C

omplete genomes are getting a lot of citations, but that isn't, as the leader of the latest team to enter the lists modestly tells Science Watch, "because they contain a lot of genes for people to cite." It is because they make sense of genuine biological mysteries. Mycobacterium tuberculosis, whose sequence is at #6, makes the case perfectly.

   John Bunyan characterized tuberculosis, the disease caused by the M. tuberculosis bacterium, as the captain of all the men of death," and more than 300 years later TB is still responsible for more deaths than any other single infectious agent. With the sequence comes a real chance to demote TB. The bare facts are these: M. tuberculosis, the H37Rv strain, was sequenced by a joint team from France's Institut Pasteur and the U.K.'s Sanger Centre. It has a genome 4,411,529 base pairs long, about 4,000 genes. That makes it a mite smaller than E. coli, but a lot more interesting.

   For example, one reason TB has proved such a scourge is that it grows very slowly and is, for the most part, benign for much of the course of the infection. The disease becomes dormant, during which time the bacterium is holed up in tubercles within the lungs, perhaps in response to an immune response that can contain, but not eradicate, the infection. As the host's immune system loses its vigor as a result of age or other infections, tuberculosis flares up again, killing the host but in the meantime infecting many new cases.

   Historically, the big question was what the bacterium was doing inside the tubercles. Researchers opined that M. tuberculosis was an obligate aerobe; at least, they were unable to grow it anaerobically in the laboratory. Because the inside of the tubercle contains little or no oxygen, M. tuberculosis must therefore be inert when inside the tubercles. That view, the sequence reveals, is probably wrong.

   "We found a set of genes that would enable it to grow anaerobically," says Julian Parkhill, a member of the team at the Sanger Centre, outside Cambridge. These genes include a previously unknown reductase that seems to represent a rearrangement of conventional nitrate reductase genes. M. tuberculosis clearly is capable of growth inside the tubercle; whether that capability is medically important remains to be seen.

   Another reason TB is difficult to treat is that it is naturally resistant to many antibiotics. That too is reflected in its sequence. Many resistance genes are encoded in the genome, including enzymes to destroy penicillins, and others that pump antibiotics out of the cell as fast as they enter. The cell envelope is possibly the main protection, being extremely hydrophilic, and M. tuberculosis boasts one of the most diverse sets of lipid metabolism genes yet uncovered.

   But perhaps the most important discovery, the one with most potential, is the existence of two completely new protein families, the PE and PPE families. The proteins are acidic and glycine rich, and their genes occupy about 10 percent of the genome. "They were previously unknown," Bart Barrell of the Sanger Centre tells Science Watch, "but one turns out to be a recognized antigen [of TB]."

   Stewart Cole, director of the French part of the team, believes that evidence that the PPE proteins are antigenic may in time lead to better vaccines. And the PE proteins are potentially immuno-suppressive. But for him, perhaps the biggest surprise was that M. tuberculosis has almost no virulence factors like the toxins seen in other pathogens. It is a surprise, however, that makes sense. M. tuberculosis is not very virulent. It sits there, slowly growing away, but does little apart from antagonize the host's immune system. "The pathology results from an excessive inflammatory reaction as the host tries to control the infection," Cole tells Science Watch. "It can be so extensive, you get tissue damage. The host kills itself, in a way."

   Critics of genome sequencing are fond of pointing out that as the sequence nears completion it becomes harder and harder to fill the gaps, and possibly not worth doing. One of the salutary lessons of the TB effort is that it ain't over till it's over. Parkhill, one of whose responsibilities was to oversee the assembly of the final sequence, puts it nicely: "If you've got a gap, you don't know what's in it, and if you can't say what's there, you don't know whether it is important." In M. tuberculosis, the gaps contained the polymorphic PE and PPE sequences, hard to clone and hard to sequence. "But," says Parkhill, "possibly the most important part of the genome."end

Science writer Dr. Jeremy Cherfas
works with the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences
Research Council of the U.K., Swindon.

Science Watch®, November/December 1999, Vol. 10, No. 6
Citing URL: http://www.sciencewatch.com/nov-dec99/sw_nov-dec99_page8.htm

Search | November/December 1999 Index | Archives | Contact | Home

What's New in Research - (Updated weekly) - What's NEW in Research
The Most-Cited Researchers in...
  |  Analysis Of...  |  Site Map by Field | ! QUICK SCIENCE !
Alphabetized List of All Essential Science Indicators Editorial Features/Interviews


Science Watch® is an editorial component of Essential Science Indicators. RSS Feeds for Essential Science Indicator's editorial Web sites
Visit other editorial components of ESI: "in-cites" and "Special Topics."
Write to the Webmaster with questions or comments about this site. Terms of Usage.
View all the products of the Research Services Group from Thomson Scientific.


(c) 2008 The Thomson Corporation.
Thomson Scientific