


|
The Large and Small of Australian Research |
by
Christopher King
|
|

or
its latest survey of university and institutional research, Science Watch
returns to Australia, last covered more than a decade ago (7[4]: 1-2,
July/August 1996). In this update, Australian institutions are ranked according
to two main measures: impact (average citations per paper) and total citations,
based on papers published and cited in Thomson Scientific-indexed journals
between 2002 and 2006. The first table below lists the top 3 finishers in each of 21
fields according to impact. Institutions are ranked according to
total citations in the second table below. A third
table provides two additional measures, listing the
most-prolific Australian institutions in terms of paper output during the
five-year period, as well as those that display the highest overall
cites-per-paper scores.
These rankings are based on figures from the standard version of Thomson
Scientific’s Australian University Indicators 1981-2006, a database
containing publication and citation statistics for more than 50 universities
and research institutes. This coverage represents an expansion over the
initial edition of Thomson’s Australian database (and the 1996 survey in
these pages), which only reflected university research. The current figures
include such facilities as the Howard Florey Institute and the Peter
MacCallum Cancer Center. (Note: the research institutes in the database were
all considered separately, and their papers and citations were not included
with any of the universities with which they might be affiliated. For
example, papers from the Howard Florey Institute were not included with
those from the University of Melbourne, even in instances where the
institutions appear together within a single author-address listing.)
The research institutes, as it happens, make a good showing in the impact
tables, despite generally publishing fewer papers than powerhouses such as
the University of Sydney and the University of Melbourne. In molecular
biology & genetics, for example, the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of
Medical Research (WEHI), with its 164 Thomson-indexed papers in the field,
and the Peter MacCallum Cancer Center, with 101, take the top two spots for
impact, as they also do in the field of immunology. WEHI, in fact, as the
third table shows, outscores all other universities and institutions in
overall impact, with an average of nearly 20 citations per paper. WEHI also
registers in the total-citations rankings, in molecular biology & genetics,
immunology, and even mathematics—the latter thanks to a handful of papers
that include highly cited bioinformatics reports from Statistica Sinica
on statistical methods for identifying gene expression in microarray
experiments.
In some of the fields ranked by impact, a few smaller-producing
institutions lost out due to the varying thresholds of paper output set by
Science Watch for each field (in order to account for differences in
journal populations and citation patterns between specialty areas). In
physics, for example, Griffith University scored a solid 5.65 cites per
paper, but the university’s paper count of 161 was below the threshold of
200 set for this survey. Similarly, the Institute of Advanced Studies
registered an impact mark of 6.45 in chemistry, but its output of 128 chem
papers was shy of the field’s 200-paper threshold.
Output, needless to say, was no problem for the large, heavy-hitting
universities that dominate the rankings here, as they did in the previous
survey. The most-prolific schools, as shown in the third table—the
universities of Sydney, Queensland, Melbourne, and New South Wales—each
appear in at least 9 of the total-citations rankings and at least 5 of the
impact listings. On this score, perhaps the University of Melbourne did best
of all: 11 appearances by total citations, 10 by impact, and "Top 3"
placements for both impact and total citations in 5 fields: physics,
neurosciences, pharmacology, microbiology, and psychology/psychiatry.

|

Top 3 Australian Institutions in 21 Fields, 2002-06
Ranked by average citations per
paper (in parentheses)

|
Field |
1
|
2
|
3
|
|
Physics
|
U. Adelaide
(5.97) |
U. Melbourne
(5.88) |
U. Sydney
(5.36) |
|
Molec.
Bio./Genetics |
Walter & Eliza Hall
Inst.
(25.55) |
Peter MacCallum Cancer
Ctr.
(18.85) |
U. Queensland
(14.37) |
|
Chemistry
|
U. New South Wales
(6.76) |
U. Sydney
(5.35) |
U. Melbourne
(5.26) |
|
Biology &
Biochemistry |
Walter & Eliza Hall
Inst.
(19.64) |
Garvan Inst. Med. Res.
(14.26) |
Howard Florey Inst.
(12.16) |
|
Materials Science |
U. Melbourne
(5.18) |
U. Queensland
(2.75) |
U. Sydney
(2.74) |
|
Neurosciences |
U. Melbourne
(7.43) |
U. Western Australia
(7.20) |
U. New South Wales
(7.16) |
|
Engineering
|
U. Melbourne
(2.77) |
U. Sydney
(2.48) |
Australian Natl. U.
(2.34) |
|
Geosciences
|
Curtin U. Technol.
(6.18) |
Australian Natl. U.
(5.84) |
Macquarie U.
(5.19) |
|
Pharmacology
|
Howard Florey Inst.
(10.34) |
U. Melbourne
(7.21) |
Flinders U.
(6.74) |
|
Space Science
|
U. New South Wales
(15.65) |
Australian Natl. U.
(15.22) |
U. Melbourne
(10.12) |
|
Clinical Medicine
|
Walter & Eliza Hall
Inst.
(23.51) |
Garvan Inst. Med. Res
(13.39) |
Baker Med. Res. Inst.
(12.48) |
|
Computer Science
|
Queensland U. Tech.
(3.71) |
U. Queensland
(2.57) |
Monash U.
(2.38) |
|
Microbiology
|
U. Melbourne
(9.37) |
Australian Natl. U.
(8.21) |
Queensland Inst. Med.
(8.02) |
|
Mathematics |
U. Newcastle
(2.27) |
U. New South Wales
(1.96) |
U. Western Australia
(1.72) |
|
Ecology/Environment
|
Macquarie U.
(9.24) |
James Cook U.
(6.63) |
U. Queensland
(5.67) |
|
Agricultural
Sciences |
U. Sydney
(4.60) |
U. Adelaide
(4.42) |
U. Melbourne
(3.05) |
|
Immunology |
Peter MacCallum Cancer
Ctr.
(25.33) |
Walter & Eliza Hall
Res. Inst. (22.51) |
U. Western Australia
(12.49) |
|
Plant & Animal
Science |
Australian Natl. U.
(5.37) |
U. Western Australia
(4.51) |
U. Adelaide
(4.21) |
|
Psychology/Psychiatry |
U. New South Wales
(4.93) |
U. Melbourne
(4.81) |
U. Newcastle
(4.43) |
|
Education
|
Curtin U. Technol.
(1.86) |
U. Queensland
(1.38) |
U. Sydney
(1.35) |
|
Economics &
Business |
Queensland U. Tech.
(2.50) |
U. Western Australia
(2.47) |
U. Tech. Sydney
(2.11) |
|
^top |
SOURCE: Thomson
Scientific
Australian University Indicators |
|

Top 3 Australian Institutions in 21 Fields, 2002-06
Ranked by total citations (in parentheses)

|
Field
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
|
Physics
|
Australian Natl. U
(6,934) |
U. Sydney
(6,383)
|
U. Melbourne
(5,075) |
|
Molec.
Bio./Genetics |
U. Queensland
(6,091)
|
Walter & Eliza Hall
Inst.
(4,191) |
U. Melbourne
(2,843) |
|
Chemistry |
U. New South Wales
(6,399) |
U. Sydney
(6,144)
|
Monash U.
(5,150) |
|
Biology &
Biochemistry |
U. Sydney
(8,273)
|
U. Queensland
(7,852)
|
U. Melbourne
(7,321) |
|
Materials Science |
Monash U.
(1,065)
|
U. Queensland
(1,049)
|
U. Sydney
(930) |
|
Neurosciences |
U. Melbourne
(5,585)
|
U. New South Wales
(4,530) |
U. Sydney
(4,147) |
|
Engineering
|
U. New South Wales
(1,798) |
U. Sydney
(1,786)
|
U. Melbourne
(1,663) |
|
Geosciences
|
Australian Natl. U.
(5,518) |
U. Western Australia
(2,058) |
Curtin U. Technol.
(1,947) |
|
Pharmacology
|
U. Queensland
(1,609)
|
Monash U.
(1,567)
|
U. Melbourne
(1,507) |
|
Space Science
|
Australian Natl. U.
(8,689) |
U. New South Wales
(3,897) |
U. Sydney
(3,141)
|
|
Clinical Medicine |
U. Sydney
(32,420)
|
U. Melbourne
(20,573)
|
U. New South Wales
(17,848) |
|
Computer Science
|
U. Melbourne
(312)
|
U. New South Wales
(281) |
Queensland U. Tech.
(278) |
|
Microbiology
|
U. Melbourne
(3,147)
|
U. Queensland
(2,856)
|
U. New South Wales
(1,856) |
|
Mathematics
|
U. New South Wales
(546) |
Walter & Eliza Hall
Inst.
(506) |
Australian Natl. U.
(447) |
|
Ecology/Environment
|
U. Queensland
(2,755)
|
Macquarie U.
(1,719)
|
James Cook U.
(1,637) |
|
Agricultural
Sciences |
U. Adelaide
(1,048)
|
U. Sydney
(975)
|
U. Western Australia
(918) |
|
Immunology
|
Walter & Eliza Hall
Res. Inst.
(5,469) |
Monash U.
(2,651)
|
Peter MacCallum Canc.
Ctr.(2,330) |
|
Plant & Animal
Science |
U. Queensland
(3,943)
|
Australian Natl. U.
(3,728) |
U. Western Australia
(3,456) |
|
Psychology/Psychiatry |
U. New South Wales
(3,309) |
U. Melbourne
(3,128)
|
U. Queensland
(2,546) |
|
Education
|
U. Queensland
(117)
|
Curtin U. Technol.
(95) |
U. Sydney
(89)
|
|
Economics &
Business |
U. Melbourne
(644)
|
U. New South Wales
(567) |
Australian Natl. U.
(538) |
|
^top |
SOURCE: Thomson
Scientific
Australian University Indicators |
|
|

Overall: Highest in Output and
Impact
 |
Most Prolific
. |
|
Rank |
Institution |
Papers
02-06 |
|
1 |
U. Sydney |
13,325 |
|
2 |
U. Queensland |
11,503 |
|
3 |
U. Melbourne |
11,220 |
|
4 |
U. New South
Wales |
9,588 |
|
5 |
Monash |
8,516 |
|
6 |
Australian
Natl. U. |
8,104 |
|
7 |
U. Western
Australia |
7,093 |
|
8 |
U. Adelaide
|
6,201 |
|
9 |
U. Newcastle |
2,847 |
|
10 |
Queensland U.
Tech. |
2,617 |
|
Highest Impact
(All fields, >300 papers 2002-06) |
|
Rank |
Institution |
Papers
02-06 |
|
1 |
Walter & Eliza
Hall Inst. |
19.52 |
|
2 |
Garvan Inst.
Med. Res. |
13.73 |
|
3 |
P. MacCallum
Cancer Ctr. |
12.37 |
|
4 |
Baker Med.
Res. Inst. |
11.71 |
|
5 |
Queensland
Inst. Med. |
9.21 |
|
6 |
Howard Florey
Inst. |
8.95 |
|
7 |
Murdoch Child.
Res. Inst. |
6.96 |
|
8 |
Inst. Adv.
Studies |
6.61 |
|
9 |
Australian
Natl. |
5.71 |
|
10 |
U. New South
Wales |
5.45 |
|
|
|
|
 |
Related links: an
interview with
Dr. Terry
Speed. Quote from interview:
“…the field of microarray data analysis is expanding
rapidly, and many people like me are getting involved.”
|
 |
Download this article in a
Adobe .PDF file. |
 |
Science
Watch®, September/October 2007, Vol. 18, No. 5
Citing URL: http://www.sciencewatch.com/sept-oct2007/sw_sept-oct2007_page1.htm |
|